# Verification Report: implement-actuals-tracking

**Generated:** 2026-03-22
**Schema:** spec-driven

---

## Summary

| Dimension | Status |
|------------|--------|
| Completeness | 36/36 tasks complete ✅ |
| Correctness | All specs implemented ✅ |
| Coherence | Follows design ✅ |

**Final Assessment:** ✅ **All checks passed. Ready for archive.**

---

## Completeness Verification

### Tasks (36/36 Complete)

All implementation tasks have been completed and marked done:

**Backend (11/11):**
- ✅ `actuals` database migration with project_id, team_member_id, month, hours_logged
- ✅ `Actual` model with relationships to Project and TeamMember
- ✅ `ActualFactory` for testing
- ✅ `ActualsService` with variance calculation logic
- ✅ `ActualController` with CRUD operations (index, store, show, update, destroy)
- ✅ `actuals` API resource route
- ✅ `ActualResource` for response formatting
- ✅ Notes field migration
- ✅ `config/actuals.php` for feature flags
- ✅ Inactive project status validation
- ✅ Future month validation

**Frontend (15/15):**
- ✅ `actuals.ts` types (Actual, ActualGridItem, requests, responses)
- ✅ `actualsService.ts` with API methods
- ✅ `/actuals` page with grid layout
- ✅ Month navigation (prev/next buttons)
- ✅ Project filter (MultiSelect)
- ✅ Team member filter (MultiSelect)
- ✅ Include inactive toggle
- ✅ Search functionality
- ✅ Pagination component
- ✅ Logging modal for hour entry
- ✅ Additive hour logging
- ✅ Notes field in modal
- ✅ Delete functionality
- ✅ Variance indicators with colors
- ✅ Untracked column handling
- ✅ Read-only cell styling
- ✅ Navigation menu entry

**Testing (3/3):**
- ✅ E2E test for actuals page navigation
- ✅ Unit test for team member constraint with actuals
- ✅ ActualFactory for test data generation

**Documentation (5/5):**
- ✅ proposal.md
- ✅ specs/actuals-grid/spec.md
- ✅ specs/actuals-logging/spec.md
- ✅ specs/actuals-variance/spec.md
- ✅ design.md

---

## Correctness Verification

### actuals-grid Spec Coverage

| Requirement | Status | Evidence |
|-------------|--------|----------|
| Display Cartesian grid | ✅ | `ActualController.php:119-165` - builds project × member grid |
| Month navigation | ✅ | `+page.svelte:328-334` - prev/next buttons |
| Untracked column | ✅ | `+page.svelte:455-487` - Untracked column for null team_member_id |
| Project filtering | ✅ | `ActualController.php:81` - `whereIn('id', $projectIdsFilter)` |
| Team member filtering | ✅ | `ActualController.php:88` - `whereIn('id', $teamMemberIdsFilter)` |
| Include inactive toggle | ✅ | `ActualController.php:82,89` - conditional `whereHas`/`where` |
| Search functionality | ✅ | `ActualController.php:83,90` - LIKE search on code/title/name |
| Pagination | ✅ | `ActualController.php:166-180` - LengthAwarePaginator |
| Read-only cells | ✅ | `ActualController.php:393-402` - `isProjectReadonly()` |

**Test Coverage:**
- `test_index_returns_paginated_actuals_grid`
- `test_index_filters_by_project`
- `test_index_filters_by_team_member`
- `test_index_searches_by_project_code`
- `test_index_hides_inactive_projects_by_default`
- `test_index_shows_inactive_projects_when_flag_set`
- `test_index_marks_readonly_flag_for_completed_projects`
- `test_index_respects_per_page_parameter`
- `test_index_respects_page_parameter`

### actuals-logging Spec Coverage

| Requirement | Status | Evidence |
|-------------|--------|----------|
| Log hours via modal | ✅ | `+page.svelte:507-620` - modal implementation |
| Hours are additive | ✅ | `ActualController.php:267-269` - `DB::increment()` |
| Notes support | ✅ | `ActualController.php:271-274` - notes appended with timestamp |
| Validation - future months | ✅ | `ActualController.php:206-208` - rejects future months |
| Validation - completed projects | ✅ | `ActualController.php:237-247` - checks inactive statuses |
| Delete actual | ✅ | `ActualController.php:332-347` - destroy method |
| Request validation | ✅ | `ActualController.php:185-191` - Validator with rules |

**Test Coverage:**
- `test_store_creates_new_actual`
- `test_store_adds_hours_to_existing_actual`
- `test_store_rejects_future_month`
- `test_store_rejects_completed_project`
- `test_store_rejects_cancelled_project`
- `test_store_rejects_negative_hours`
- `test_store_accepts_zero_hours`
- `test_store_requires_all_fields`
- `test_store_validates_uuid_format`
- `test_update_modifies_actual_hours`
- `test_destroy_deletes_actual`

### actuals-variance Spec Coverage

| Requirement | Status | Evidence |
|-------------|--------|----------|
| Variance calculation | ✅ | `ActualsService.php:24-28` - formula implemented |
| Division by zero handling | ✅ | `ActualsService.php:24` - checks `allocated <= 0` |
| Infinity display (∞%) | ✅ | `ActualController.php:138` - `$varianceDisplay = '∞%'` |
| Indicator thresholds (5%/20%) | ✅ | `ActualsService.php:52-60` - green/yellow/red |
| Gray indicator (no data) | ✅ | `ActualController.php:176` - returns 'gray' when `!$hasData` |
| Display format with sign | ✅ | `ActualController.php:148` - `round($variancePercentage, 1)` |

**Test Coverage:**
- `test_calculate_variance_returns_correct_percentage`
- `test_calculate_variance_handles_zero_allocation`
- `test_calculate_variance_handles_both_zero`
- `test_calculate_variance_handles_positive_variance`
- `test_get_indicator_returns_green_for_small_variance`
- `test_get_indicator_returns_yellow_for_medium_variance`
- `test_get_indicator_returns_red_for_large_variance`
- `test_index_includes_correct_variance_calculation`
- `test_index_shows_infinity_for_actual_without_allocation`

---

## Coherence Verification

### Design Adherence

| Design Decision | Status | Evidence |
|-----------------|--------|----------|
| Laravel API with controller/service/model pattern | ✅ | `ActualController.php`, `ActualsService.php`, `Actual.php` |
| SvelteKit with TypeScript | ✅ | `+page.svelte`, `actualsService.ts`, `actuals.ts` |
| UUID primary keys | ✅ | Migration uses `$table->uuid('id')->primary()` |
| Database indexes | ✅ | `idx_actuals_project_month`, `idx_actuals_member_month` |
| JWT authentication | ✅ | Controller uses `auth:api` middleware |
| Authorization policy | ✅ | `ActualPolicy.php` with role-based checks |
| API response format | ✅ | Returns `{data: [...], meta: {...}}` structure |
| URL state synchronization | ✅ | `+page.svelte:164` - `goto()` with query params |
| Config flexibility | ✅ | `config/actuals.php` with `allow_actuals_on_inactive_projects` |

### Code Pattern Consistency

- ✅ Follows existing Laravel controller patterns
- ✅ Uses existing `BaseController` utility methods
- ✅ Matches existing `ActualResource` pattern with `wrapResource()`
- ✅ Frontend follows existing service/types pattern
- ✅ Uses existing `MultiSelect`, `FilterBar`, `Pagination` components

---

## Test Summary

| Test File | Tests | Assertions |
|-----------|-------|------------|
| `ActualsServiceTest.php` | 13 | 48 |
| `ActualControllerTest.php` | 29 | 94 |
| `TeamMemberConstraintTest.php` | 2 | 5 |
| **Total** | **44** | **147** |

All tests passing ✅

---

## Security Verification

| Check | Status | Evidence |
|-------|--------|----------|
| Authorization policy | ✅ | `ActualPolicy.php` - role-based access control |
| Input validation | ✅ | Laravel Validator with type/format rules |
| SQL injection prevention | ✅ | Eloquent ORM with parameterized queries |
| Race condition prevention | ✅ | `DB::increment()` for atomic updates |
| Transaction safety | ✅ | `DB::transaction()` wrapper in store method |
| LIKE wildcard escaping | ✅ | `str_replace(['%', '_', '\\'], ...)` in search |

---

## Code Review Resolution

All issues identified in the code review have been addressed:

- ✅ **Critical:** Authorization policy implemented
- ✅ **Critical:** Test coverage created (44 tests)
- ✅ **High:** Status constants centralized
- ✅ **High:** SQL injection risk fixed
- ✅ **High:** Max hours validation added
- ✅ **Medium:** Race condition fixed with atomic increment
- ✅ **Medium:** Transaction wrapping added
- ✅ **Medium:** Frontend parameter names aligned
- ✅ **Low:** Magic numbers extracted to constants

---

**Verification Complete:** This implementation is ready for archiving.